Spend the extra $$ and buy Genuine BMW or EMP Stewart

I purchased one last year in October. it started leaking in less than 11 months. very disappointing considering my original laste on lasted 10 years.

This Graf pump failed dramatically with no advance warning. No prior coolant loss. Failed at highway speed, expelling all coolant. Observant son saw temp needle rise, red light on gauge go on, and steam. Turned heat to full and came to a safe stop moments later. Replaced this pump with a Carquest special I could get locally. Won't buy a Graf again.

I have a 98 E36 328i Fit perfectly no issues.

I have 2 different e46’s I installed this on. First one for 40k miles / 2 years the inner small o ring went and leaked coolant everywhere. Second one absolutely mangled itself and left marks inside the timing cover and the motor. The shaft had separated from the water pump. Will definitely switch to another brand this one’s terrible do not buy!!!!

Installed in January 2020 on my 2006 X5 and 35k miles later, leaking like crazy all of a sudden. Going with Meyle this time around.

Disappointed to run into bearing play and noise after a mere 8 months/4,000 miles. Will likely go with Meyle for a replacement.

Failed after one month. Started squealing on start up after two weeks, huge leak from weep hole, the whole pump wiggles left to right which I believe indicates blown bearing. Terrible product and now gonne have to redo the whole thing.

Bought and installed this water pump three and a half years ago based on reviews commending its metal blade. But the bearing completely failed this week, causing coolant leak and other damages.

Great replacement.