I have replaced thermostat, coolant temp sensor, radiator, and water pump with this pump above and my radiator fan runs 99% of the time on max speed. What are the chances that this water pump has failed after a few months and a few thousand miles? I know there is the lifetime warranty to replace it but I don't want to pay for the labor again. Thanks!
It's absolutely impossible for us to say without diagnostic information. The fan, water pump, thermostat, etc are all controlled over the drivetrain canbus system. Any one failed components in this system can cause erratic behavior of other components. It's not likely a new water pump has failed in 1000 miles. It's more likely there is another component that is causing unusual behavior/performance.